The top Democrat on the House Armed Services Committee said Sunday that surveillance video of U.S. military strikes targeting an alleged drug trafficking vessel in the Caribbean Sea on Sept. 2 would contradict how Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth and other Republicans have described it. 

“When they [the survivors] were finally taken out, they weren’t trying to flip the boat over. The boat was clearly incapacitated. A tiny portion of it remained, capsized, the bow of the boat. They had no communications device. Certainly, they were unarmed,” Rep. Adam Smith, one of the Democratic lawmakers who saw the video, said. “Any claim that the drugs had somehow survived that attack is hard, hard to really square with what we saw.”

Smith called the video “deeply disturbing” and said “it did not appear that these two survivors were in any position to continue the fight.” 

That’s counter to how Hegseth and Republican Sen. Tom Cotton, the chair of the Senate Intelligence Committee who also viewed the video, have described the circumstances preceding the second strike. 

Cotton told reporters he had no doubt about the legality of the strike and said he “saw two survivors trying to flip a boat loaded with drugs bound for the United States back over so they could stay in the fight.”

On Saturday, Hegseth recounted what he had been told about the subsequent strike.

“I was told, ‘hey, there had to be a reattack, because there were a couple folks who could still be in the fight. Access to radios. There was a link up point of another potential boat, drugs were still there. They were actively interacting with them,’” the secretary said at the Reagan National Defense Forum. 

Asked by “This Week” anchor George Stephanopoulos about Hegseth’s comments, Smith said, “That’s ridiculous. There are no radios.”

“They ought to release the video,” Smith said. “If they release the video, then everything that the Republicans are saying will clearly be portrayed to be completely false. And people will get a look at it, and they will see. The boat was adrift. It was going where the current was going to take it, and these two were trying to figure out how to survive.”

President Donald Trump has said the administration would have “no problem” releasing the video of the strike in question, but Hegseth was noncommittal when asked Saturday. 

“Whatever we were to decide to release, we’d have to be very responsible about it so we’re reviewing that right now.,” Hegseth said at the Reagan National Defense Forum. “I’m way more interested in protecting that than anything else. So, we’re viewing the process, and we’ll see.”

Smith argued the strike video lawmakers were shown is “no different” than the strike videos the administration has already publicly released. 

“It seems pretty clear they don’t want to release this video because they don’t want people to see it, because it’s very, very difficult to justify,” he said. 

Sen. Eric Schmitt, a Republican member of the Armed Services Committee who has not seen the video, defended the administration in a separate interview on “This Week.” 

“The fact is, these cartels now, because the southern border is closed, they’ve gone to the high seas. So President Trump is acting with his core Article II powers. No serious legal expert would doubt that the president has authority to blow narco-terrorists out of the water,” Schmitt said. 

The Missouri senator continued, “President Trump has been delegated the authority by Congress to designate terrorist organizations. He’s done that. He sent a letter to Congress saying he was going to initiate these strikes. We’ve had regular briefings about it.”

Schmitt argued the criticism from Democrats amounts to “politics and trying to take out Secretary Hegseth.”  

On Saturday, Hegseth said designating cartels as terrorist organizations makes them a “target” just like al-Qaida. But the legality of the entire operation targeting these vessels has been a central debate, and legal experts have questioned the administration’s justification. 

“If you say anyone who has drugs that they’re intending to illegally transit to the U.S. is a legitimate target for deadly force, the amount of power that gives the president and the U.S. military is unprecedented, and something that ought to be concerning to all of the American people,” Smith, the top Armed Services Democrat, said on “This Week.” 

Schmitt, however, insisted the strikes are legal.

“They’re completely authorized. I reviewed the 40-plus page memo by the Office of Legal Counsel. There’s [Judge Advocates General] officers in these rooms, George, every time there’s a strike,” Schmitt said. 

The opinion by the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel has not been made public. Democrats have called for it to be released.